top of page

Truth, Trauma, and Allegations in Child Sexual Abuse (CSA) Cases

drdayadmin
4 days ago
2 min read

Psychological Affiliates’ Kyle Goodwin, Melvin Pagan, and Christine Hammond presented with the Honorable Christopher Sprysenski at the 17th Symposium on Child Custody for the Association of Family and Conciliation Courts on November 7, 2026, in Orlando, Florida. They presented a workshop on dealing with the complexities of child sexual abuse (CSA) allegations in family law matters. 



Their presentation outlined a multidisciplinary framework for navigating CSA allegations within therapeutic and legal contexts. They emphasized the necessity of maintaining forensic neutrality, avoiding contamination of child disclosures, and integrating multiple data sources to inform court proceedings. Their presentation underscores that neither a standard psychological evaluation nor a forensic interview is sufficient, in isolation, to determine whether abuse occurred. Instead, professionals must synthesize records, clinical interviews, collateral information, and psychological testing to test well-reasoned hypotheses. 



5 key takeaways from their presentation included:


  1. Prioritize Forensic Integrity and Neutrality: When a professional is the first to hear a disclosure, they must stop and ensure the appropriate authorities are notified. To prevent contamination of a child’s account, professionals must avoid leading questions, coaching, or excessive questioning by multiple parties, as these can compromise the reliability of the information.


  1. Distinguish Evaluation Types: A child’s psychological evaluation (focusing on functioning, trauma, and treatment needs) is distinct from a forensic child interview conducted by Child Protective Services (focusing on eliciting an account of alleged abuse using neutral, developmentally appropriate techniques). Neither process alone definitively determines the occurrence of abuse.


  1. Integrate Multiple Data Sources: Forensic opinions must be based on the convergence of evidence. This includes court records, CPS/law enforcement reports, medical and mental health records, collateral interviews, and psychological testing. No single data point should determine the final opinion.


  1. Acknowledge Complexity and Context: Professionals must account for the context of disclosures, including cultural factors, potential for delayed disclosure, and the reconstructive nature of memory. In high-conflict divorce cases, professionals must critically analyze their own biases, assumptions, and competencies when interpreting allegations.


  1. Collaborative Approach to Reunification: The ultimate goal is the child’s best interest. This requires ongoing, transparent collaboration between therapists, evaluators, and the court to manage high-conflict dynamics, support family healing, and implement appropriate therapeutic remedies when clinically and legally indicated.


Comments


bottom of page